image
Book a Demo to Save up to 17% on Measurement Reports, Unlock FREE ProData Reports, SmartQuotes™, Material Lists, and Receive a $25 Gift Card -   Click to Schedule Your Demo Today

What Carriers Should Ask Before Standardizing a Measurement Vendor

4 minute read

https://roofscope.com/image/cache/catalog/2025/2026/VendorHeader-812x387.png

written by RoofScope published on 11. 16. 2026

Adam Cordova

Most carriers choose a roof measurement vendor on price, then find out what they really bought during their first big CAT. That's when SLAs slip, reports come back needing rework, and claims that should close stay open.

Price is always the first question I get, and it matters. On a quiet day, most vendors look alike, so picking the cheapest one feels reasonable. That's why I ask carriers to let me walk through everything else before we talk price. When a carrier reviews its measurement vendor, price is one of four reasons. The other three are accuracy, ease of use, and billing that doesn't fit how the carrier pays. During a CAT, a fifth shows up fast: SLAs that can't keep up with demand.

Carriers also tend to stay with the vendor they're used to, because changing feels harder than living with the problems. If you're weighing a change or standardizing across your network, there are six things insurance carriers should evaluate in a roof measurement vendor besides price: accuracy, native integration, SLAs during a CAT, your hardest addresses, billing fit, and minimums.

1. How accurate is it, and how is the report made?

Accuracy is where the evaluation should start, and many stop at "are you accurate?"

"What they should be asking is how we derive our reports."

Adam Cordova

Ask who draws the report, who checks it, and what happens when the imagery is bad. Ask how the vendor defines accuracy and what that number is measured against. For your own test, have an adjuster go out and hand-measure a few roofs and compare the hand measurement to the report. That's the best way to do it.

Not every measurement report is the same, so look at what's in it. Does it break out the two-story sections? In Xactimate and XactAnalysis, two-story is an additional cost on the claim. If the report misses it, the claim gets extended. Pull your past claims data and compare vendors apples to apples, down to what half a square does to a claim and to your speed to claim closeout.

And when a measurement does look wrong, ask who you'll talk to, whether they'll rework it, and how fast the corrected report comes back. Watch for a chat queue and a 24 to 48 hour callback.

2. Does it work natively inside Xactimate, XactAnalysis and Cotality?

For many carriers, this is a hard filter. They tell me if you're not integrated with Xactimate, they won't even talk to you. If a standardization is going to break, it breaks inside Xactimate and XactAnalysis. One carrier put it to me this way: "Adam, I don't want to be in Xactimate and have to toggle off."

XactAnalysis is the platform carriers use to manage and assign claims. Xactimate is the tool adjusters use to write the estimate. A real integration has to work in both.

Most serious vendors are integrated with Xactimate, XactAnalysis and Cotality now, so being integrated won't separate them on its own. The difference is how far the integration reaches. Ask whether the vendor is a Verisk partner with a native Xactimate integration, whether they're live in XactAnalysis and Cotality, and then ask them to walk you through the full flow, live, on a real claim:

  • Can your adjusters order the report from the claim itself?
  • When it comes back, does it land in Sketch, so they can map it with macros and build out the roof claim without redrawing it?
  • Do they also get the 2D image and a PDF of the drawing for the file?
  • Does it work for every workflow you run: carrier staff, outside adjusters, and contractors?

When a big storm hits, your IA firms deploy CAT teams to handle the volume. If those outside adjusters can't order through the integration, your standardization stops at exactly the moment you need it.

Then ask which third-party workflow tools the vendor is live with. Many carriers run tools on top of Xactimate, XactAnalysis and Cotality that need to trigger orders, and those integrations take time to set up. Carriers tend to underestimate that step, so budget for it and ask who on the vendor's side owns onboarding.

3. Where does our account sit in the queue during a CAT?

Everybody wants reports in one to three hours. The test is a hurricane or a major hail event. Large providers may have SLAs with tier-one carriers, and when demand spikes, those accounts come first. Tier-two and tier-three carriers become secondary, and their SLAs get longer right when they need speed most.

Ask the vendor whether every carrier gets the same SLA during a CAT, or whether the biggest accounts get priority. Then ask for actual delivery times, not just the SLA on paper.

4. Will you prove it on our hardest addresses?

Don't test a vendor on easy roofs. Ask your adjusters for the addresses your current provider sent back with an email saying they couldn't do them, and send those to every vendor you're evaluating. That's what I ask carriers for: send me those addresses.

A carrier told me that out in the sticks, all his provider could give him was a 2D image. He'd have to sketch the roof himself, which took about half an hour to an hour every time.

5. Will it fit how we pay?

More carriers are bringing accounts payable into these meetings, and for good reason. Every carrier bills differently. Some use QuickBooks, some use an outside billing platform, and one hired a developer to build its own system. Ask whether reports can be billed into the claim, whether the vendor accepts payment from a claim escrow account or through bulk accounts, whether the claim number follows through on every invoice under your net terms, and whether you get a receipt you can attach straight to the claim file.

6. Do you require minimums?

When we first went to market with volume-based pricing tied to a claims commitment, carriers told us flat out that if we required a minimum, they'd walk.

"So nobody wants to do minimums. That's a big thing right now."

Adam Cordova

Ask whether the pricing requires a volume commitment, and what happens to your rate in a slow storm season.

Where we stand

We're an Xactimate, XactAnalysis and Cotality partner, and our native integration covers the carrier, adjuster, and contractor workflows. Today that's for roof reports. People draw our reports, a team of 300+ CAD technicians, and carriers ask if we have 500 people in the office. Our 99% accuracy guarantee is measured as a fleet-wide flag rate, and reworks come back in about an hour.

We look at all carriers as one. Rush is a paid option with a three-hour SLA, and when we commit to three hours, we deliver in three hours. Standard enterprise SLAs are within 12 hours, and year to date in 2026, our average delivery time on standard residential RoofScope reports, not counting rush orders, is four hours and six minutes. Commercial, multifamily, and low slope are 24 hours. Most of the time, reports are billed into the claim with the claim number on every invoice, and we don't require minimums.

RoofScope delivery times: rush SLA 3 hours, 2026 year-to-date standard residential average 4 hours 6 minutes, standard enterprise SLA within 12 hours, commercial 24 hours.
RoofScope delivery times
Rush SLA (paid option)3 hours
2026 year-to-date average, standard residential (not counting rush)4 hours 6 minutes
Standard enterprise SLAWithin 12 hours
Commercial, multifamily and low slope24 hours

Start with the hard addresses

Pull the addresses your current provider couldn't do and send them to me, or to any vendor you're evaluating.

Send Adam your addresses

written by RoofScope published on 11. 16. 2026

SHARE ON